The spirit photographs of William Hope
Flickr set of the spirit photographs of William Hope shared by the National Media Museum.
The group became renowned as the “Crewe Circle” with William Hope as its leader. During their early efforts, the circle destroyed all of the negatives of the photos they took for fear of being suspected of witchcraft. However, when Archbishop Thomas Colley, a lifelong enthusiast of both the supernatural and Spiritualism, joined the circle, they began to make their work public.
Ironically, Hope’s first brush with exposure as a fraud came when Archbishop Colley arranged his first sitting. According to the story, Hope doctored the photograph with the wrong spirit extra, substituting another elderly woman for Colley’s mother.
When Hope tried to confess his fraud to Colley, the other man dismissed his confession as “nonsense”– he would recognize his mother when he saw her and the extra in the photo was certainly his mother, he stated. To prove his case, he even put a notice in the local newspaper and asked that all of those who remembered his mother should call at the rectory. No fewer than 18 people selected Hope’s mistake from among several others and said that it definitely showed the ghost of the late Mrs. Colley.
Arthur Conan Doyle was a proponent of Hope’s, and his book The Case for Spirit Photography was written in support, after a separate controversial incident involving suspected fraud.